Trending
Politics

The Anatomy of the Nigerian Economic Crisis: Beyond the Subsidy Smokescreen

Published November 20, 2026 · admin
Advertisement
FSM

By Itunu Abioro (A Concerned Nigerian)

In the ongoing debate about the state of the Nigerian economy, a convenient narrative has taken hold: that the removal of the petrol subsidy was the singular, magic bullet that cured a dying nation. We are told that before 2023, the country was held hostage by a subsidy racket, and that the current “pain” is a necessary, temporary price for a reboot.

This narrative is seductive in its simplicity, but it is dangerously incomplete. It ignores deep, structural rot that predates the subsidy debate and has not been solved by its removal. To accept it is to be gaslit by selective data.

Let us, therefore, dissect the components of this crisis with the precision they deserve.

  1. The Road Tax Scam: Where Are the Trillions?

The argument goes that previous governments could not build roads because all the money went to petrol subsidy. This ignores a massive, parallel revenue stream that has been systematically looted for decades: road taxes collected by transport unions.

The primary justification for the daily “tickets” and levies collected by the NURTW, RTEAN, and their affiliates is that these funds are for road maintenance and construction. Yet, a 2026 investigation revealed a staggering discrepancy in Rivers State alone: the state generated ₦55 billion annually from road taxes, but only ₦223.93 million—a mere 0.4%—ever entered the government treasury. The rest vanished into the black hole of union coffers and private pockets.

This is not an isolated case. It is a national plague. Successive state governments, like Edo, have been forced to ban these unions from revenue collection entirely due to “widespread extortion” and “economic sabotage”. The money for the roads has been collected. It was just never spent on the roads. Blaming subsidy for bad roads is a convenient distraction from the fact that a separate, colossal road fund has been hijacked by a union oligarchy.

  1. The Education Paradox: Loans for a Broken System

We are told that NELFUND (the student loan scheme) is the great equalizer, allowing poor students to access education. But what is the point of funding access to a system that is structurally obsolete? NELFUND has disbursed over ₦282 billion, offering up to ₦20,000 monthly for upkeep. Yet, the scheme is riddled with contradictions.

Most damningly, students of the National Open University of Nigeria (NOUN)—the very institution designed for flexible, distance learning—are ineligible for the loan because they do not possess a JAMB number. This is bureaucratic absurdity.

The deeper issue, however, is the model of education itself. In an era of Open Educational Resources (like Harvard’s Open Source lectures and NOUN’s downloadable materials), why is the cost of education still so exorbitant? The true value of education is technology transfer and employability, not the purchase of a certificate. We are borrowing money to fund a system that produces graduates with skills that do not match the demands of the 21st-century economy. The solution is not more loans for a broken model; it is the radical restructuring of the model itself, from certificates to skills.

  1. The Macroeconomic Trap: Debt, Hot Money, and Bank Windfalls

The cost-of-living crisis is not solely a function of subsidy removal. It is the result of a toxic macroeconomic cocktail that predates 2023 and has been exacerbated by current policy.

· The Debt Overhang: Nigeria is servicing debts taken during the Buhari administration, which are now due. This is a massive fiscal drain.
· The Hot Money Trap: To attract volatile foreign portfolio investment (FPI) and stabilize the naira, the Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) is paying exorbitant interest rates. While standard Treasury bills yield around 17%, the CBN’s OMO bills are being auctioned at near 22% to keep foreign “hot money” from fleeing. This is a short-term fix that creates an unsustainable long-term interest burden.
· The Bank Windfall: The ultimate irony is who profits from this misery. The devaluation of the naira and high interest rates led to massive windfall gains for Nigerian banks. In the midst of national hardship, institutions like GTCO recorded a 108% increase in profits (reaching ₦1.27 trillion), and UBA’s profit after tax grew by 26.14% to ₦766.6 billion. The system is designed to transfer wealth from the struggling citizen to the financial elite.

  1. The Cement Paradox: Profiting from National Pain

Perhaps the most egregious example of corporate exploitation is the cement industry. Dangote, the dominant player, has publicly confirmed that cement exported from Nigeria is sold cheaper abroad than it is domestically.

His defense is that exports are exempt from the crushing domestic tax regime. He lists the burdens: 30% income tax, 2% education levy, 1% health levy, 7.5% VAT, and 10% withholding tax. This is a legitimate point about Nigeria’s harsh business environment. However, it does not fully explain the scale of the markup.

Dangote’s average selling price has been reported at around ₦170,493 per tonne, while production costs are a fraction of that. The company’s profit after tax surged by 31.1% to ₦974.79 billion in just nine months. This is not just a story of high taxes; it is a story of a cartel exploiting a captive market. The solution is not to beg them to lower prices, but to break their oligopoly by encouraging alternative building materials—like the laterite-silicate blocks and agro-waste bricks that can be produced locally at a fraction of the cost.

  1. The “Energy Security” Slush Fund

Finally, the claim that subsidy removal has saved the nation is undermined by the opaque “Energy Security Expenses.” While the government claims to have saved trillions, the Nigerian National Petroleum Company Limited (NNPCL) recorded ₦7.13 trillion in “energy security expenses” in 2024 alone. Critics, including former Vice President Atiku Abubakar, have demanded a forensic audit, questioning what this money actually covers.

If the subsidy is truly gone, why are billions still being spent under a different name? The suspicion is that a new, less transparent subsidy regime has been created—one that enriches a new set of middlemen and political cronies. The fiscal hemorrhage has not stopped; it has merely been rebranded.

Conclusion: The Real Work Has Not Begun

The removal of the petrol subsidy was a necessary, if painful, step. But it was never going to be sufficient. It was a fiscal band-aid on a patient suffering from multiple, systemic infections: a looted road tax system, an obsolete education model, a predatory banking sector, a monopolistic cement cartel, and an opaque energy security regime.

To claim that the “symptoms of national death disappeared” is a dangerous fantasy. The symptoms have merely mutated. True leadership does not just remove a subsidy; it builds the alternative infrastructure—economic, educational, and physical—that allows the nation to thrive without it. Until we confront these deeper structures, we are simply rearranging the deck chairs on a sinking ship.

Itunu Abioro is the Ogbeni Oja of Grassroots Politics and a Senatorial Candidate for Ogun West. He writes from Ipokia.

FSMAdvertisement
Advertisement
FSM